Pin it
Irresistible Italian Sub Mini Sandwiches
I'm always thrilled to share my crowd-pleasing party food, and these Italian Sub Mini Sandwiches are truly knockout snacks. Every mouthful explodes with delicious Italian cold cuts, gooey provolone and tangy peppers. Take my word for it - once these show up at your get-together, everyone will want to know how you made them.
Why These Mini Sandwiches Never Let Me Down
As someone who throws a lot of parties, I can't stress enough how much a simple but wow-worthy recipe matters. These little sandwiches have come to my rescue many times during big game days and family celebrations. What's really great is how adaptable they are. Got more mouths to feed? Just buy more rolls and up the filling amounts. They're so quick to put together, you'll still have tons of time to chat with your friends.
My Favorite Tried and Tested Components
- Hawaiian rolls: I always reach for Kings Hawaiian - their touch of sweetness works magic against the hearty fillings.
- Deli ham: Spending extra on Applegate Black Forest Ham makes a real difference in taste.
- Salami: Columbus Italian Dry Salami brings that genuine Italian deli flavor.
- Sliced pepperoni: The smoky notes in Applegate pepperoni can't be matched.
- Provolone cheese: Ask for fresh-sliced at the deli for the dreamiest melt.
- Hot cherry peppers: I swear by Mezzetta brand for just the right heat kick.
- Peperoncini: A handful of Mezzetta peperoncini adds zip to each bite.
- Butter: Nothing tops Kerrygold salted butter for richness.
- Italian seasoning: Don't hold back - this is what delivers that classic flavor.
- Fresh garlic: The smell of freshly crushed garlic takes these over the top.
How I Whip These Sandwiches Up
- Stack all those tasty layers:
- Cut those rolls straight across the middle. Load up pepperoni, salami, ham, provolone and those tangy peppers, then place the tops back on.
- My flavor-packed butter mix:
- Get that butter melted down and stir in your garlic and Italian herbs. Brush this amazing mixture generously over everything.
- The cooking trick:
- Wrap them in foil and stick them in a 350°F oven for about 30 minutes. When they come out all toasty and cheese-melty, slice them apart and watch how fast they vanish.
Common Questions From Friends
- Too spicy for your taste? The peppers add just a mild warmth. If you want something gentler, try sweet banana peppers or roasted red peppers instead.
- Need to serve lots of people? Easy fix. This recipe scales up wonderfully. Just get more packages of rolls.
- Can't track down Kings Hawaiian? Don't worry - any type of connected dinner rolls will do the job.
My Favorite Serving Suggestion
Want to know the best way to enjoy these little gems? Serve them right after they come out of the oven when they're still warm and the cheese is all stretchy. Put a small dish of marinara sauce nearby for dipping - the combo of flavors is absolutely fantastic.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I make these in advance?
- Yes, prep them earlier in the day, wrap them up in the fridge, and wait to butter and bake until serving time.
- → How do I store leftovers properly?
- Put any extras in a closed container in the fridge for 2 days. Heat them back up in the oven at 350°F to crisp the bread.
- → Can I switch up the meats?
- Go for it! Sub in turkey, mortadella, or roast beef instead of the suggested meats if you prefer.
- → Why use foil when baking?
- It stops the tops from browning too fast while the cheese melts. Foil also locks in steam, making the sliders soft and gooey.
- → Do I really need marinara sauce?
- Not at all! The sliders taste amazing on their own. But marinara is a fun extra for those who like dipping.