Pin it
When December comes around, these thumbprints are always my first holiday treat. There's something magical about how the butter meets sweet jam, or perhaps it's those tiny pools of fruity goodness nestled in each one. They always take me back to warm moments baking with my family during the festive season.
The Charm Behind These Delightful Cookies
I'm crazy about how these cookies balance simplicity with elegance. They're fantastic when the kids want to join the baking fun - those little indentations were practically designed for small fingers. The best part? You can customize the fillings based on everyone's preferences, making them so enjoyable to create and give away.
Your Required Ingredients
- All-Purpose Flour: Two and a half cups creates our soft, tender foundation.
- Salted Butter: One full cup softened to room temperature for that melt-away texture.
- White Sugar: A cup provides just enough sweetness without going overboard.
- Baking Powder: Half a teaspoon to give them a bit of lift.
- Egg: A single large egg binds everything nicely.
- Pure Vanilla Extract: Two teaspoons for that rich, warm flavor I can't get enough of.
- Jam: Roughly a cup of whatever flavor makes your taste buds dance.
The Baking Process
- Mix the basics:
- Beat your butter, sugar and baking powder until they're light and airy, it'll take several minutes but don't rush this step.
- Wet ingredients next:
- Stir in the egg and vanilla, don't forget to clean off the sides of your mixing bowl.
- Add the dry stuff:
- Fold in your flour just until combined, overmixing will make tough cookies.
- Getting hands-on:
- Form small balls and press those thumbprints into each one, leaving room between them on your tray.
- The finishing touch:
- Spoon in your jam and bake until you see those edges turning a light golden color.
- Cool down time:
- Let them sit on the pan briefly before moving to a cooling rack.
Secrets For Cookie Success
Putting your dough in the fridge for a bit makes it way easier to handle. When making those dents, aim for something not too shallow or deep, around half an inch works great. Be careful with the jam amount too. You want them full but contained, so those edges stay golden instead of turning dark.
Storage Solutions
These treats stay yummy for about five days when you keep them in a sealed container. I usually put some parchment between the rows to keep them looking nice. They're also great for freezing, which comes in handy when you need to get ahead during those crazy holiday weeks.
Try Different Filling Options
Though raspberry jam is my go-to, these cookies taste amazing with lots of different fillings. Sometimes I'll switch to lemon curd for something tangy or chocolate spread when I'm catering to the chocolate lovers in my house. Making a variety in one batch means everyone can pick what they love best.
Festive Favorite
These thumbprint cookies just scream holiday spirit to me. That combo of buttery dough and sweet center brings so much happiness to Christmas gatherings. Each time I bake them, I can't help thinking about all the wonderful times they've helped us create throughout the years.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What jams should I use?
- Any smooth, thick jam will work. Raspberry and strawberry are popular, but pick what you love.
- → Why turn the baking tray?
- Moving the tray ensures all cookies bake evenly. This keeps them puffing up and browning nicely.
- → Can the indent go deeper?
- You can press the centers further, but not too much. Keep the cookie sturdy so it holds the jam well.
- → How long do they stay fresh?
- They last about a week in a sealed container. Keep layers separate with wax paper to avoid sticking.
- → Can these be frozen?
- Absolutely! Freeze in an airtight box with wax paper between layers. They'll last for 3 months.