Pin it
The holiday season turns my kitchen into a memory palace while I whip up these treasured Italian Christmas Cookies. As the sweet smell fills the air, I'm transported to grandma's cooking space where I took my first steps making these treats. They're wonderfully soft, buttery, and topped with bright sprinkles - my favorite way to dish out some holiday spirit.
An Irresistible Cookie That Unites Everyone
What I adore about these cookies is how they bring all kinds of bakers to the kitchen. You don't need fancy stuff or tricky methods, making them great for quick surprises or handmade presents. Watching people's eyes light up when they taste these soft buttery bites makes every minute spent baking them totally worth it.
Your Ingredient List
- All-Purpose Flour: I always use 3 cups to nail that soft, tender bite.
- Butter: You'll want a whole cup brought to room temp for that melt-away feeling.
- Granulated Sugar: Three-fourths cup hits the sweetness spot perfectly.
- Eggs: Grab two large ones to bind everything nicely.
- Baking Powder: One tablespoon helps create their airy texture.
- Vanilla Extract: Just one teaspoon, though sometimes I swap in almond or anise for a twist.
- For the Glaze: You'll mix up powdered sugar with milk and add those happy-making colorful sprinkles.
Creating Kitchen Wonder
- Setting up:
- Make sure everything's measured out and sitting at room temperature - it really counts.
- Mixing basics:
- Beat your butter, sugar and vanilla until fluffy and light, then drop in those eggs one by one.
- The dry stuff:
- Combine your flour and baking powder, then slowly work it in. Keep working the dough until it feels just perfect.
- Patience pays off:
- Wrap your dough up tight and stick it in the fridge for an hour - you'll find shaping much simpler.
- Creative forming:
- Form small round balls or try twisting into spirals - they'll look amazing either way.
- Baking time:
- Pop them in until you see just a hint of gold on the bottom, then let them sit before moving them.
- Sweet finale:
- Stir up your glaze, dunk those cooled treats and sprinkle generously. Let them dry until they shine.
Clever Baking Tips
Don't rush getting your butter soft enough. Yeah, chilling the dough seems like extra work but it really helps when you're shaping. Handle the dough gently and grab the cookies from the oven right when the edges start to set. Wait till they're completely cool before you add that gorgeous glaze.
Spreading Joy
You can keep these treats fresh about a week if you store them in something airtight at room temp, and they can go in the freezer for up to 3 months. I'm a big fan of tucking them into cute boxes with ribbons for gifts. They always put smiles on faces wherever they go.
Creating Treasured Moments
These Italian Christmas cookies have grown into an essential part of my holiday customs. Whether I'm baking with my loved ones, bringing them to parties, or giving them as presents, their sweet charm never stops bringing happiness and building wonderful memories.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Why should the dough be chilled?
Cooling the dough makes handling easier and helps keep the cookies from spreading too much in the oven.
- → Can these cookies go in the freezer?
Absolutely. Store them without glaze for up to three months. Thaw fully before decorating and enjoying.
- → Why is soft butter necessary?
Using butter at room temperature makes the dough blend better. It helps keep the cookies soft and evenly mixed.
- → How long until the glaze hardens?
The glaze should fully harden in about 30–60 minutes. Let the cookies cool completely first to avoid melting the glaze.
- → What’s the best way to store them?
Keep them in a sealed container at room temperature for up to a week. Use wax paper between layers to avoid sticking together.
Conclusion
Cakey, light, and coated in a smooth vanilla glaze, these Italian cookies stand out with colorful sprinkles. A true holiday favorite that’s great for sharing with loved ones.