Pin it
Every time I make these buckeye candies, I'm transported to grandma's kitchen. Each one delivers a velvety peanut butter center surrounded by decadent chocolate - creating something truly magical with every taste. I've tweaked her traditional method over the years until I got it just right for my kids and husband.
Irresistible Comfort Candy
What makes buckeyes so wonderful is how straightforward they are - just a handful of simple ingredients coming together in something extraordinary. The mix of salt and sweetness with my little twist makes them absolutely addictive. Anyone who samples these treats always asks me how I make them.
What You'll Need
- Smooth peanut butter avoid the natural kind it's too runny
- Unsalted cream butter softened to room temperature
- Rich brown sugar for extra flavor
- Confectioners sugar finely sifted
- Premium chocolate for coating I prefer melting discs
Let's Create Wonders
- Begin with the Filling
- Whip peanut butter and butter till fluffy add brown sugar salt and vanilla until well combined
- Powder Power
- Gradually add confectioners sugar watching as the consistency changes
- Forming Beauties
- Form into small balls place on parchment to cool and firm up
- Melting Magic
- Gently melt chocolate stirring to achieve perfect smoothness
- Finishing Flourish
- Partially dip each ball leaving the top bare blend away toothpick marks allow to harden
My Helpful Hints
Don't dump all your sugar in at once or you'll end up with lumps. I always weigh my ingredients for consistent results. Really take your time with the mixing part and you'll find shaping them becomes super easy.
Pin it
Storage Smarts
You can leave your buckeyes out for a day or two, or stick them in the fridge for up to two weeks. They'll stay good in the freezer for several months, but honestly, they vanish quickly at my place. They taste great whether cool or at room temp.
Tasty Traditions
Buckeyes first came from Ohio, named after the nuts from their state tree. These days these sweet treats bring joy everywhere. It's amazing how the most basic treats often become family favorites.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Why skip natural peanut butter?
It can cause texture issues and might separate. Stick with regular peanut butter for smoother results.
- → Do I need coconut oil?
It makes the chocolate silkier for dipping. You can skip it, but the chocolate might be thicker.
- → How long do these stay good?
They’re fine at room temp for 2 days, in the fridge for up to 3 weeks, or frozen for a few months.
- → What’s the benefit of freezing before dipping?
Cold balls hold up better when coated, making dipping much cleaner and easier.
- → What if the mixture is sticky?
Add powdered sugar slowly until it firms up enough to roll without sticking.