Tasty 5-Ingredient Roll Ups

Nothing hits the spot like homemade tortilla pizza spirals straight from your air fryer. After trying dozens of ways to satisfy my kids' snack cravings, I finally nailed this awesome technique that's now our family's favorite for weekend movies and surprise visits. These cheesy swirls combine gooey cheese, tasty pepperoni, and crunchy tortillas so well you'll forget delivery was even an option.

The first batch I made for my daughter's friends vanished in minutes, forcing me to whip up more. These days I always double the recipe since my husband sneaks them while they're still cooling down!

Smart Ingredient Breakdown

• Flour Tortillas: Go for the 8-inch size every time. I tried the bigger ones but they just won't get that nice crunch
• Pizza Sauce: Pick something chunky. I found out that runny sauce just makes everything mushy
• String Cheese: Stick with basic mozzarella sticks – they give you that amazing stretchy pull
• Pepperoni: The standard size works way better, since tiny ones tumble out when rolling
• Olive Oil: Brush it on rather than spray. I tried both and brushing makes them golden every time

Save

Tasty Roll Up Instructions

Set Everything Out:

Put all your stuff within reach first – it really makes everything go smoother

Soften Your Tortillas:

Pop them between wet paper towels for half a minute to make them bend without breaking

Add Your Sauce:

Put a spoonful near the bottom, leaving empty space around the edges

Stack Your Fillings:

Put pepperoni in a line, then place your cut string cheese pieces on top

Wrap It Up:

Tuck the sides in slightly and roll from bottom to top, keeping it tight

Oil The Outside:

Brush the whole thing with olive oil, being careful to coat the edges too

Cook Them Up:

Put them in your air fryer with the seam facing down and let it do its thing

I've ruined plenty of these while figuring out what works. Looking back, using bagged shredded cheese was my worst move – it just doesn't melt as smoothly as string cheese. My teen still won't let me forget about what we now call the "great cheese explosion of 2023."

Pair With These Sides

Since adding these to our rotation, Friday dinners got so much easier. I usually set out warm marinara for dipping, throw together a quick Caesar, and sometimes add garlic bread if I'm feeling extra. When friends pop by without warning, I can cook these up fast and look totally prepared.

Try These Variations

Sometimes I just grab whatever's in the fridge and go wild. Last week's leftover chicken mixed with buffalo sauce was amazing! My kids now beg for what we call the "pizza-dilla" where I mix taco spices into the sauce. Even my super-picky niece who runs from anything green loves them packed with spinach and ricotta.

Storage Solutions

Soggy leftovers are the worst, aren't they? I stack mine in containers with paper towels between them. When it's time to eat them again, skip the microwave completely. A quick run through the air fryer makes them crispy again. Though honestly, we rarely have any left!

Better Than Frozen

Those store-bought pizza bites we all grew up with? These totally blow them away. My friend Katie borrowed my air fryer so often to make these that her husband finally got them their own for Christmas. Now our kids run between our houses comparing our different twists on the recipe.

Fancy Alternatives

On special nights I'll swap in prosciutto for pepperoni, or add some sweet caramelized onions. During garden season when I've got too much basil, I tuck a few leaves inside before rolling. You can try almost anything and somehow they still turn out great.

Save

Smart Cooking Advice

• Wait a minute before biting in – hot cheese can really burn your mouth
• Don't forget that oil brush step – it's what gives you that restaurant-style crunch
• Keep working with warm tortillas – cold ones will crack open

After testing pizza methods for years, from standard oven baking to grilling, these air fryer spirals have become my go-to choice. They're fast enough for crazy weeknights when everyone's busy, but still impressive enough when friends come over.

And guess what? My mother-in-law actually asked me how I make them, which never happens since she's usually the one giving cooking tips! Whether you need to feed hungry kids after practice or want easy snacks for game night, these roll ups always satisfy. Just make more than you think you'll need – they vanish faster than you can say "dinner's ready!"

Recipe FAQs

→ Why heat tortillas first?

It softens them up, preventing cracking while rolling. A damp paper towel works great to keep them flexible.

→ Can I switch up the fillings?

Totally! Swap in any meats, cheeses, or veggies you like, but avoid overfilling—keep amounts small.

→ Why cook seam-side down?

Keeps everything snug during cooking by sealing edges in place.

→ Can I prep these early?

For sure! Roll them up, store in the fridge for up to 4 days, and reheat in the air fryer at 360°F for 1-2 minutes.

→ Do I really need oil?

Yep! Brushing on oil gives that amazing crispy outside. It's worth it!