Pin it
During the festive season, I can't wait to whip up this eye-catching Sugar Cookie Cheesecake. It feels like a beautiful mashup of my top dessert picks in one incredible treat. I adore how the smooth cheesecake cuddles those chunks of cookie dough and sits on that rich shortbread base—it just makes me smile. Topping it all with colorful sprinkles turns it into Christmas happiness you can eat.
Two Beloved Treats Brilliantly Combined
This creation always gets oohs and aahs around my holiday gatherings. The combo of sugar cookies with cheesecake creates something truly special. That slightly tart sour cream layer on top cuts through the sweetness perfectly, making each forkful absolutely wonderful.
Your Shopping List
- For your Buttery Base:
- The foundation starts with flour
- Sweetness comes from powdered sugar
- Don't forget salt to wake up flavors
- Butter at room temp pulls everything together
- A splash of milk for the right texture
- For that Luscious Middle:
- Warm up three packages of cream cheese
- Granulated sugar adds sweetness
- Almond and vanilla extracts give cookie vibes
- Eggs help with the structure
- A bit of flour helps stop cracking
- For Cookie Treasure Chunks:
- Room temp butter forms the foundation
- Sugar gives that authentic cookie taste
- Add flour to create the right consistency
- Colorful sprinkles for extra cheer
- For the Finishing Touch:
- Rich sour cream
- A dusting of powdered sugar
- More festive sprinkles to make it pop
Crafting Your Showstopper
- Build your foundation:
- Combine shortbread components, push into your springform, and bake until lightly golden. Your kitchen will smell fantastic.
- Make those cookie bits:
- Blend butter with sugar and flour until it feels like real cookie dough, then shape into tiny balls.
- Mix the main attraction:
- Whip cream cheese until completely smooth, drop in eggs one at a time, then gently stir in your cookie dough balls.
- Putting it together:
- Pour your mixture onto the baked crust, place in a water bath, and bake till barely jiggly. Let it cool slowly for best results.
- Add the final layer:
- Whip up your sweet sour cream mix, smooth over the top, and finish with a happy handful of sprinkles.
My Insider Cheesecake Tips
Don't rush the process of bringing ingredients to room temp—it really affects how smooth your cheesecake turns out. Yes, the water bath is worth the extra effort for super creamy results. And don't worry about small cracks since they'll disappear under that lovely frosting anyway.
Storage Smarts
This beauty stays good in your fridge for up to seven days. I often make it days before a party and just add the topping right before guests arrive. You can even freeze it for longer storage if you want to plan way ahead.
Personalize Your Creation
Switch up your sprinkle colors to match any celebration throughout the year. Need to skip gluten? Just swap in your trusted gluten-free flour mix. I sometimes add a hint of peppermint to the cookie dough bits when I want extra Christmas flair.
Festive Dessert Wonder
This cheesecake has grown into a must-have part of my holiday baking lineup. Those surprise cookie dough bits and bright sprinkles always get everyone excited. There's something truly magical about combining two favorite desserts into one stunning holiday centerpiece.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → How does a water bath help?
- It keeps the oven moist, so the cheesecake cooks evenly and stays smooth without cracks.
- → Why use room-temperature ingredients?
- It ensures everything mixes well, giving you a great batter without lumps or unevenness.
- → Is this good for prepping ahead?
- Absolutely, the cheesecake needs chilling overnight. You can store it in the fridge for around 5 days.
- → What if there are cracks on top?
- Cracks might form from the cookie dough, but frosting hides them easily. Use a smooth tool if needed.
- → Why cool it down slowly?
- Taking time to cool prevents sudden changes, keeping the cheesecake smooth and intact.