Save
Every bite of brown sugar pop tart cookies takes you right back to being a kid. Imagine the cozy taste of cinnamon brown sugar pop tarts paired with that soft, melt-in-your-mouth cookie texture. You’ll hit a gooey cinnamon core under the light, cake-like shell, making these treats feel way more exciting than any old cookie.
On my first try with these, I was flooded with childhood nostalgia. The second my house filled up with that brown sugar-cinnamon smell, I knew I’d nailed it. My kids' faces totally lit up when they found that sweet surprise inside—so worth the extra steps.
Tasty Ingredient Guide
- Cornstarch: Grab a fresh, powdery cornstarch without chunks—this gives you a cloud-like cookie
- Ground Cinnamon: Go with extra fragrant cinnamon to really boost that pop tart flavor vibe
- Light Brown Sugar: Get soft and lump-free brown sugar for smooth mixing and maximum gooeyness
- Unsalted Butter: Splurge on high-fat butter (check for 82% fat or more) for major flavor
- Cake Flour: Use cake flour that’s fresh and measured right for that pillow-soft finish
Flawless Gooey Middles
- Chilling And Wrapping:
- Roll your filling balls and fully wrap with cold dough—seal them up so nothing leaks out. Roll in your hands for a smooth finish.
- Filling Blend:
- Press brown sugar and cinnamon tight together into little balls. Firm them up so they're easy to wrap in dough.
- Add The Dry Mix:
- Fold your dry ingredients in gently—stop once things come together. Don’t keep mixing or you’ll end up with tough cookies.
- Whip The Butter First:
- Let your butter hang out until soft, then whip it up till it’s fluffy and pale. This gets you a light cookie base.
- Add Sugars Then Eggs:
- Slowly beat both sugars into the fluffy butter, mixing each in fully. Crack eggs in one by one, mixing to a smooth blend before moving on.
Save
Found out from my chef buddy that an extra 15-minute chill really sets these cookies up for baking success. Tried it and won’t go back—the texture comes out perfect every time now.
Snack Time Pairings
For the full treat, grab a cold glass of milk or a hot cup of coffee. Try making ice cream sandwiches by smooshing vanilla ice cream between two cookies. For something fancier, stack ’em with fresh berries and a little caramel drizzle.
Yummy Ways To Switch It Up
Level up the filling with chopped nuts or swap in some maple extract for cozy fall flavors. If you’re a chocolate fan, add cocoa powder to your dough and go with a creamy chocolate center. On holidays, grab colored sprinkles and jazz up your glaze for extra festive fun.
How To Keep Them Fresh
Let cookies chill out till cool, then stack in a tight container with wax paper between layers so they stay pretty. Good for 3 days on the counter, up to a week in the fridge. Stick extras in the freezer (unjazzed) for 3 months, then bring to room temp and glaze before munching.
After loads of experimenting and taste tests, I’m sure: these cookies spark pure happiness. That mix of soft shell and gooey brown sugar filling is unbeatable. Whether you’re in it for the nostalgia or creating new family traditions, they never fail to make people smile.
Save
Recipe FAQs
- → How do I tell if my butter's ready to use?
- Let butter sit out for 1-2 hours until slightly cool but not warm, around 60°F. If it's too soft, cookies could flatten.
- → Is it okay to freeze these cookies?
- Sure! Store baked, unglazed ones for 3 months in the freezer. Or, freeze dough balls and bake straight from frozen.
- → Why is chilling the dough important?
- It keeps the cookies from flattening and makes stuffing simpler. For dough chilled over an hour, let it sit for 30 mins to soften.
- → What's the best way to keep these cookies fresh?
- Pop them in a sealed container for up to 3 days on the counter, or up to a week if refrigerated.
- → Can I bake smaller ones?
- The recommended size is 1/4 cup to hold the filling. Smaller sizes might lead to leaks during baking.