Creamy Orzo Butternut Squash

I found this rich orzo dish last autumn when I had butternut squash on my counter and needed a quick dinner fix. It's turned into one of my go-to weeknight meals! The mix of velvety pasta, caramelized squash and bright spinach makes a comfort food that feels both luxurious and nourishing at once.

My fussy 6-year-old, who usually avoids anything green, actually wanted more the last time I cooked this. That's when I knew I had something truly amazing!

What You'll Need

• Orzo: This grain-shaped pasta forms a wonderful creamy foundation. Pick any brand you like.
• Butternut squash: Buy it already cut if you're short on time, though whole ones cost less.
• Fresh spinach: Don't worry about the huge pile - it shrinks down amazingly fast.
• Chicken stock: Gives rich flavor as the orzo simmers right in it.
• Heavy cream: Just a tiny bit creates that smooth, silky texture. You can use half-and-half too.
• Garlic: Go with fresh cloves for the best flavor kick.
• Italian seasoning: This single blend adds lots of flavor without needing tons of different spices.

Pin it

How I Make It

Squash Shortcut

I chop my butternut squash into tinier cubes than most cooks suggest - they cook quicker and mix better throughout the dish. Coating with olive oil, salt and pepper before baking brings out their natural sweetness.

Orzo Magic

Don't skip browning the dry orzo in some oil before adding your liquid - this step adds amazing nutty flavor. Then I slowly pour in warm stock, stirring often like you would for risotto. This makes that dreamy, smooth texture without needing tons of cream.

Wilting Wonders

Throwing in the spinach at the very end keeps its vibrant color and stops it from getting mushy. I just let the hot pasta do the work of softening it - no extra cooking needed!

Finishing Touches

A tiny pour of cream at the end, once off the heat, keeps it from breaking down or reducing too much. I always taste and fix the seasoning last since stocks can vary in saltiness.

I found out how great high-heat squash roasting is (425°F instead of the usual 375°F) purely because I was in a rush one night. The higher temp makes those yummy browned edges while keeping the middle soft - total game changer!

Serving Ideas

This works great as a meal by itself, but I often pair it with a simple arugula salad with just lemon and olive oil. If you're not vegetarian, it goes perfectly with roasted chicken or pan-seared scallops. When friends come over, I bring it to the table in a wide, shallow bowl and everyone can help themselves.

Make It Your Own

Try using sweet potatoes when butternut isn't around. Add cooked mushrooms for earthy flavor. Mix in some browned Italian sausage or shredded store-bought chicken for protein. Want it lighter? Use plain almond milk instead of cream. Sprinkle toasted pine nuts on top for crunch and nutty taste.

Storage Smarts

This stays good in your fridge for 3-4 days, though it will get thicker as it sits. When warming it up, add a splash of stock or water to thin it back out. I often cook twice as much just for work lunches through the week - it heats up great in the office microwave.

Pin it

Smart Tricks

• Cook extra squash while you're at it for other meals later in the week
• Add some freshly grated lemon zest on top for brightness that balances the creaminess
• Pour a bit of quality olive oil over everything just before eating for extra richness

This velvety orzo creation has come to my rescue countless times at dinner. There's something about its soothing, smooth texture and colorful veggies that feels like comfort in a bowl. Even on my most tired weeknights, I can throw this together without much effort and still feel like I've made something special for dinner!

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I use frozen squash instead of fresh?

Definitely! Thaw it beforehand and pat dry. It cooks quicker, so reduce roasting by about 5 minutes.

→ How can I make this a lighter dish?

Swap heavy cream for half-and-half, whole milk, or evaporated milk. It won’t be as rich but still tasty. Coconut or cashew cream works too if you’re avoiding dairy.

→ Can I prep anything in advance?

Yes! Roast the squash up to two days early and refrigerate. When it’s mealtime, cook the orzo and stir in the prepped squash to reheat.

→ What protein pairs well with it?

This meal works great with chicken, salmon, or shrimp. If you're going vegetarian, mix in white beans or chickpeas.

→ What can I use instead of orzo?

Small pasta shapes like ditalini or tiny shells work too. Adjust the amount of liquid and cooking time based on the pasta instructions.