Save
A club sandwich is one of those timeless lunches that never disappoints. Layered with fresh tomato juicy turkey slices crisp lettuce smoky bacon ham and creamy mayo all stacked between toasted bread this classic is not only filling but incredibly satisfying. Perfect for sharing and ideal for a simple hearty meal this version is just like the one diners serve—only better because you made it at home.
When I first made this sandwich after a long hike my family practically cheered at the table. Now it is our go to after busy mornings because it feels extra special yet comes together in no time.
Ingredients
- Sandwich bread: Choose a good quality soft loaf for the best texture Toasting brings out extra flavor and holds up to all the fillings
- Turkey breast: Opt for freshly sliced at the deli for more moisture and better flavor than pre packed
- Ham: Look for ham with a little marbling for the best savory bite
- White american cheese: Melts perfectly and gives a creamy salty layer You can pick a different cheese if you prefer something stronger
- Bacon: Cook until crispy but still a bit chewy Thick cut holds up best
- Tomato: Slice fresh and use ripe tomatoes for juiciness and acidity I love heirloom if available
- Shredded lettuce: Romaine or iceberg both add cool crunch Wash well and dry fully so your sandwich is not soggy
- Mayo or spicy mayo: Adds richness and brings all the flavors together Use your favorite brand or make it spicy with a hint of hot sauce
Step by Step Instructions
- Toast the Bread:
- Begin by toasting all the slices of bread just until golden This keeps the sandwich sturdy and brings flavor
- Prep Veggies and Bacon:
- Slice your tomato into even slices and shred the lettuce Cook your bacon until crisp but not dry Drain on a paper towel and set aside
- First Layer Assembly:
- Lay out the first piece of toasted bread and slather one side with mayo Add turkey slices evenly then arrange tomato slices on top Layer a slice of white american cheese over the tomatoes
- Middle Bread Layer:
- Place the second slice of mayo spread bread mayo side down Press gently so it adheres Smear more mayo on top of this layer
- Second Layer Assembly:
- On top of the second bread layer lay down slices of ham then bacon making sure each bite will have both Top with a generous handful of shredded lettuce
- Final Bread Cap and Secure:
- Crown your sandwich with the final slice of bread mayo side down Press gently then insert sandwich picks into each quadrant Slice into four triangles for the classic club look
- Repeat and Serve:
- Repeat the above steps to make your second sandwich Serve immediately with chips or your favorite sides
Save
Making this sandwich always brings back memories of family picnics We would wrap them in wax paper and by lunchtime the flavors would meld perfectly Nothing beats the anticipation of that first crunchy bite
Storage Tips
While this club sandwich is best enjoyed fresh it can be made a few hours in advance Wrap tightly in parchment and foil to keep the bread from drying No mayo on the outer layer helps prevent sogginess Refrigerate and consume the same day for best quality
Ingredient Substitutions
Feel free to switch turkey for chicken or sub in roast beef if you prefer Swap white american cheese for cheddar or Swiss Add avocado slices for even more creaminess For a lighter version try using low fat mayo and turkey bacon
Save
Serving Suggestions
These sandwiches are classic with potato chips or fries For a bistro feel add a side salad or pickles Clubs also pack well for picnics Just keep them tightly wrapped and chilled until ready to eat
Cultural and Historical Context
The club sandwich is said to have first appeared in American country clubs at the turn of the twentieth century It quickly became a symbol of casual sophistication at lunch tables and diners across the country Its triple decker layers set it apart from even the best deli sandwiches
Recipe FAQs
- → What is the best bread for a club sandwich?
Toasted white sandwich bread is classic for structure and crunch, but whole wheat or sourdough can offer extra flavor and texture.
- → Can I substitute other meats for turkey or ham?
Yes, chicken breast or roast beef are popular alternatives. Adjust seasonings to balance the flavors with your substitutes.
- → Is it necessary to use bacon?
Bacon adds smoked, crisp texture, but you can leave it out or use turkey bacon for a lighter option.
- → What spreads work well besides mayo?
Spicy mayo, mustard, or even an herbed cream cheese can add a flavorful twist to the sandwich layers.
- → How do I keep the sandwich from falling apart?
Secure the sandwich with picks and slice with a sharp knife to keep all the layers intact and easy to serve.
- → Can I make this ahead of time?
Assemble just before serving to prevent soggy bread, but you can prep ingredients like cooked bacon and sliced vegetables in advance.