Save
Buckeye Brownie Cookies are that perfect marriage of brownies and peanut butter buckeye candies all wrapped up in an easy cookie. When I want the rich flavor of buckeyes without the fuss of dipping, this recipe is my answer for a decadent treat everyone can make in under an hour.
The first time I whipped these up for a family tailgate they vanished before halftime. My sister now asks me to bring them to every reunion and I can never resist because they are always a hit.
Ingredients
- Fudge brownie mix: get a good quality family size box for the richest base
- Butter melted: this makes the dough extra moist and gives a bakery style chew
- Cream cheese softened: this makes the cookies tender and gives a subtle richness
- Large egg: always use fresh eggs for best rise and texture
- Powdered sugar: this helps create the soft sweet peanut butter center that mimics buckeyes
- Creamy peanut butter: I look for a no stir kind for the smoothest bite avoid natural types that separate
- Semi sweet chocolate chips: my favorite is a brand with at least sixty percent cocoa for balanced flavor
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Prepare the Dough:
- Beat brownie mix melted butter cream cheese and egg together using a hand mixer or sturdy spoon until fully blended The dough will look a little sticky and thick which is perfect for chewy cookies
- Shape the Cookies:
- Scoop about two tablespoons of dough onto an ungreased baking sheet spacing evenly Roll the tops gently to form neat rounds for best appearance
- Mix the Buckeye Centers:
- In another bowl mix powdered sugar and peanut butter until smooth and cohesive The mixture should hold together easily Pinch off enough to roll into twenty four small balls around one inch in size
- Bake the Cookie Base:
- Place baking sheets in a 350 degree oven and bake for twelve minutes Watch closely to avoid over or under baking The cookies will look slightly puffed but soft in the center
- Add the Peanut Butter Balls:
- Immediately after taking cookies from the oven press a peanut butter ball gently into the center of each cookie The heat will help them meld together letting the flavors mingle
- Cool the Cookies:
- Allow the cookies to cool for five minutes on the baking sheet then move to a wire rack so they set up without getting soggy
- Melt and Top with Chocolate:
- Microwave the semi sweet chocolate chips for thirty seconds Stir well then microwave again in fifteen second spurts until smooth Spoon half a tablespoon of melted chocolate over each cookie covering the peanut butter ball Let cool until the chocolate sets for glossy irresistible tops
Save
The creamy peanut butter ball is the highlight for me I always sneak one before they hit the cookies My brother and I used to try dipping plain buckeyes together but now we trade stories while swirling chocolate over these cookies in the kitchen
Storage Tips
These cookies stay fresh in an airtight container for up to five days Room temperature is perfect unless your house is extra warm then the chocolate may soften a little To freeze layer cookies between sheets of parchment paper in a lidded container for up to three months Let them thaw at room temperature for best texture
Ingredient Substitutions
If you are out of cream cheese try Greek yogurt or sour cream for the same density and tenderness Natural peanut butter does not work as well but if you prefer it add a tablespoon of coconut oil for structure Milk chocolate chips can replace semi sweet for a sweeter finish
Serving Suggestions
Set these out for movie nights tailgates or as a fun lunchbox treat Try pairing with cold milk or strong coffee for an indulgent snack At parties stack them on a platter or make mini versions for a cute sweet bite
Save
Cultural and Historical Context
The buckeye candy is a Midwest classic celebrating that irresistible chocolate peanut butter combo Ohioans are famous for These cookies give you all that nostalgia but in a form much easier to make and share They have become a go to tradition in my home for Ohio State game days and winter cookie swaps
Recipe FAQs
- → What kind of brownie mix should I use?
A standard 19.5-ounce or family-size fudge brownie mix works best for these cookies, creating a rich chocolate base.
- → Can I substitute crunchy peanut butter?
Creamy peanut butter creates the smoothest center, but you can use crunchy for added texture if preferred.
- → How do I know when the cookies are done baking?
Bake until set around the edges but still soft in the center, about 12 minutes, to maintain a fudgy texture.
- → Should the chocolate topping be applied while the cookies are still warm?
Melted chocolate should be spooned on after the cookies have cooled slightly, so it sets evenly without running.
- → How should I store these cookies?
Keep the cookies in an airtight container at room temperature. For longer freshness, refrigerate up to one week.
- → Can I freeze these cookies?
Yes, once fully cooled and the chocolate has set, store them in layers with parchment between in a freezer-safe container.